You turn the key or press the start button and the car doesn't start. Almost always the problem is one of three parts: the battery, the starter motor or the alternator. What the car does when you try to start it usually tells you which one to suspect.
What each part does
- Battery — stores the power to crank the engine and run the electrics while the engine is off.
- Starter motor — a small, powerful electric motor that turns the engine over until it fires.
- Alternator — driven by the engine, it recharges the battery and powers the car once it's running.
Signs it's the battery
- The engine turns over slowly and sluggishly, or not at all.
- You hear rapid clicking, and the dash lights dim or flicker as you try to start.
- A jump start gets the car going and it then runs normally.
- The battery is several years old, or the car has sat unused for a while.
Loose or corroded battery terminals cause the same symptoms, so it's worth checking they're clean and tight before blaming the battery itself.
Signs it's the starter motor
- One loud click when you turn the key, but the dash lights stay bright.
- A grinding or whirring noise without the engine turning.
- It starts fine some days and not others, with no pattern.
- A jump start makes no difference.
Signs it's the alternator
- The battery warning light comes on while you're driving.
- Headlights and interior lights dim, especially at idle.
- The car starts after a jump but dies again soon after, or the battery keeps going flat.
- A whining noise from the engine bay, or a smell of hot electrics.
A failing alternator often looks like a battery problem at first: the battery goes flat because it isn't being recharged. Replacing the battery without testing the charging system can leave you with a second flat battery a few days later.
A quick check you can do
If you have a multimeter, a healthy, fully charged 12-volt battery usually reads about 12.6 volts with the engine off. With the engine running, most charging systems hold somewhere around 13.7 to 14.7 volts. A resting reading well below 12.4 volts suggests a flat or tired battery; a running reading that doesn't rise suggests the alternator isn't charging. Exact figures vary with battery type, so treat this as a guide rather than a diagnosis.
Modern cars need a little more care
Cars with start-stop systems use AGM or EFB batteries, and some makes need the new battery registered with the car's computer so it charges it correctly. Fitting the wrong type, or skipping registration where it's required, can shorten the new battery's life.
When to get help
If a jump start doesn't work, the car keeps going flat, or you'd rather not guess, a proper test of the battery, starter and charging system tells you exactly what's failed before you spend money on parts. Because the car often won't move, this is a job that suits a mobile mechanic — the testing and the repair are done where the car is parked.